10 Best Pacifiers For Breastfed babies of 2023

Next to breast milk, having the Best Pacifier for Breastfed Babies is an important acquisition to add to your breastfeeding collections.

According to the American Academy of Paediatrics (AAP), giving your baby a pacifier before bedtime can lower the risk of  Sudden Infant death Syndrome by 50%.

However, there are varieties of Pacifiers for various needs in the market, and the question is,  how do you choose the best option for your breastfed baby?

Don’t worry, this article has you covered.

We have made adequate research on the best pacifiers for breastfed babies.

With that being said, let’s get started.

Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies: Our Top picks!

1. Dr Brown’s HappyPaci 100% Silicone Pacifier: Overall best choice in the Market
2. Evenflo feeding balance plus stage 1 Cylindrical baby, new-born, and infant pacifier: First runner up, best for breastfeeding children
3. Nanobebe baby flexy pacifier: Best pick for older breastfeeding children
4. Tommee Tippee Breast-like pacifier: Best for breastfeeding babies and infants
5. WubbaNub Infant Pacifier: Best snuggie pacifier
6. MAM start newborn pacifiers: Best for breastfeeding newborns
7. NUK Silicone orthodontic pacifier: Best for easy cleaning
8. Chicco Physio-form 100% soft silicone one-piece pacifier: Best for its cute design
9. Philip Avent: Best for nighttime
10. Medela baby soft silicone pacifier: Best for breastfeeding babies and infants

Categories Of Pacifiers In The Market

When making your decisions on the pacifiers you’d want to get for your breastfeeding baby, We want to show you the various kinds of pacifiers that exist in the market, and what choice would be perfect for your breastfed baby.

1. One-piece baby Pacifiers: These are pacifiers moulded into one single component. They are made either from materials such as latex, rubber or silicon.
2. Multiple-piece baby Pacifiers: Unlike the single piece, the multiple pieces can be detached into various components such as the nipple, guard and ring. Mind you, each component is produced separately before being merged to form one conventional pacifier, you see around.
3. Latex baby Pacifiers: These sorts of pacifiers come in super-soft. You might want to make a selection of this based on its super-soft feel. The downside is that infants and older babies are at risk of choking if they end up biting off the Pacifier’s nipples.
4. Silicon Pacifiers: These are safer, durable and easily gotten from supermarkets. We advise our readers to always go for silicon options when making purchases of a pacifier.
5. Round-tip baby Pacifiers: These are usually found on conventional baby pacifiers. They are designed to mimic the shape of a mother’s nipple. This choice is preferable for breastfed babies.
6. Orthodontic baby pacifiers: These are the perfect choice of pacifiers best suited for tongue-tied babies. The nipples are more-rounded at the tip and narrower at the base to support oral development.

Products Mini-Reviews

Key Features

• Brand: Dr Brown’s 
• Age: 0-6 months 
• Material: 100% Silicone
• Toxicity: BPA free
• Type: One-piece
• Shield design: Butterfly

This is one pacifier for breastfed babies every mother should consider owning very soon.

Dr Brown’s Happy Paci One-piece Silicone Pacifier is a top option to go for considering its nipple-like shape, which creates a  smooth transition from breast to Pacifier, and vice-versa.

Made from 100% silicone material, it is incredibly lightweight and easy to handle. It comes in a one-piece modelled form and has a safety shield designed to look like a butterfly. However, this design is actually intentional as it allows for your baby’s easy breathing.  For ease in finding, you can attach a pacifier clip to its handle.

This pacifier is extremely easy to clean (dishwasher friendly) and best suited for breastfed babies between 0-6 months.

Pros	Cons
Extremely lightweight & Flexible	Paci’s handle may be too big in your baby’s hand, falling off too easily
Easily cleaned

Key Features

• Brand: Evenflo feeding
• Age: 0-6 months 
• Material: 100% Silicone
• Toxicity: BPA free
• Type: One-piece
• Shield design: Curved Faceplate

This is yet another pacifier for breastfed babies well accepted by both mothers and babies alike. With your baby’s health and safety in mind, Evenflo feeding balance+ infant pacifier was created by  Paediatrician and Feeding Specialists  to meet the needs of your breastfed baby.

This Pacifier for Breastfed Babies spots amazing features such as a cylindrically shaped nipple designed to mimic your baby’s tongue shape while he suckles.  This alone would allow for a smooth transition into breastfeeding with minimal difficulty.

Made from 100% soft silicon, the Pacifier is free from harmful additions like BPA and PVC. It also comes in a one-piece construction and is extra lightweight for your baby’s grip.

It spots air vents at the bottom which allows for the free flow of air, that prevents moisture build-up, likewise, reducing the risk of skin inflammation if used for a long period of time.

Pros	Cons
Made to imitate baby’s natural suckling position	Cylindrical-tip falls from the baby’s mouth too frequently.
Affordable

Key Features

• Brand: Nano Bebe
• Age: 0-6 months 
• Material: 100% Silicone
• Toxicity: BPA free
• Type: One-piece
• Shield design: Curved Faceplate with Ventilation holes

The Nanobebe baby flexy pacifier is another pacifier worth getting for your breastfed baby. 

This Pacifier features a flexible, one-piece modelling type that wouldn’t fall apart too easily.

Its curved face plate sits gently on your baby’s face without causing any skin-related problems like inflammations or rashes.

It is made from 100% ultra-soft silicone materials free from harmful chemicals like BPA or PVC. And the best part is its nipple-shaped tips that mimic the natural shape of a mother’s nipple. its ergonomic nipple-shaped design prevents the paci from falling off the baby’s mouth easily.

Pros	Cons
Ultra-soft & BPA free	Easily gets dirty
Sits snugly on baby’s face	2. Very hard to find when misplaced, due to clear design

Key Features

• Brand: Tommee Tippee
• Age: 0-6, 6-18 months 
• Material: 100% Silicone nipple flexes
• Toxicity: BPA free
• Type: Detachable
• Shield design: Curved Pacifier shield

The Tommee Tippee Breastlike Flexi pacifier mimics not just the shape but also the feel of a natural nipple. Your baby won’t likely tell the differences.

Made from buttery-soft silicone material, the nipple is inspired by Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature bottles and assists with pacifier acceptance.

This pacifier features a symmetrical orthodontic design for better grip during suckling.

It also spots a distinctly curved shield that sits perfectly under your baby’s without posing any risk.

Pros	Cons
BPA-free	Baby’s hand may get caught in the pacifier due to the absence of a soothie
Soft silicone nipples that mimic a natural nipple

Key Features

• Brand: Wubbanub
• Age: 0-6 months
• Material: 100% Silicone nipple flexes
• Toxicity: BPA free, PVC-Free, BPS-free
• Type: Detachable pacifier
• Shield design: Stuffed Animals

This is yet another highly recommended pacifier for breastfed babies. It doubles as a pacifier and a stuffed toy for your baby to snuggle on while he suckles.

The Wubbanub Infant Pacifier features an orthodontic nipple design, a one-piece construction model which prevents paci from getting detached so easily.

However this Pacifier should only be given to children between 0-6 months to reduce the risk of biting off and swallowing the nipple.

It is made purely from silicone materials free from toxic additions like latex, BPA and the like. It is utterly lightweight and can be easily handled by mom and baby. The stuffed toys come in varieties of animals for your selection.

Moreover, you don’t even have to struggle to wash, you can throw the pacifier into your pacifier and get the job done in no time. The stuffed toy can be machine washed.

Pros	Cons
Easy to handle	Not recommended for teething babies
BPA-free

Key Features

• Brand: MAM
• Age: 0-3 months
• Material: 100% Silicone nipple flexes
• Toxicity: BPA free, PVC-Free, BPS-free
• Type: One-piece
• Shield design: Curved shield with wide air holes

Are you a new mum and searching for the best Pacifier to get your breastfed baby? Look no further. MAM Perfect Baby pacifiers are worth giving a shot at.

Made specifically for newborns, the pacifier features a nipple 60 times thinner and 4 times more flexible than your traditional pacifier. This ingenuity alone helps to reduce the pressure of the pacifier on the lips of your little sweetheart.

The Pacifier is made from ultra-soft and 100% silicone material, this pacifier is extremely lightweight and features MAM’s unique pacifier design. Its shield has extra wide air holes to prevent saliva build-up. 

You don’t have to worry too much about protecting your baby’s pacifier from dirt, the pacifier comes with a self-sterilizing case. 

As such, you don’t have to go through the rigorous process of boiling water to sterilize. All you need to do is drop the case into your microwave, add a little water and get the job done in no less than 3 minutes.  

Pros	Cons
Comes in a unique self-sterilizing case	Suitable for newborn babies between 0-3 months
Features an ultra-thin nipple best for a newborn
BPA-free

Key Features

• Brand: NUK’s
• Age: 0-6 months
• Material: 100% Silicone nipple flexes
• Toxicity: BPA free, PVC-Free, BPS-free
• Type: One-piece
• Shield design: Curved shield with wide air holes

Nuk-sensitive orthodontic pacifier holds a commendable 60-year record of being one of the best pacifiers for breastfed babies.

 This pacifier takes up a nipple-shaped design fitting into your baby’s mouth so perfectly. The heart-shaped shield sits snugly on your baby’s face without covering his nose.

What’s more? It is so compatible with your baby’s sensitive skin and can be used for a long period of time without the fear of rashes forming later on.

Cleaning is super easy and fast. Drop into your dishwasher and watch the magic unfold. NUK pacifiers are made from 100% silicone materials and is rid of BPA.

Pros	Cons
Contains features that support oral development	Plain-looking
Heart-shaped shield for easy breathing
BPA-free

Key Features

• Brand: Chicco’s
• Age: 0-6 months, 6-12 months, 12-16 months, 16-24 months
• Material: 100% Silicone
• Toxicity: BPA free, PVC-Free, BPS-free
• Type: One-piece
• Shield design: Curved shield with wide air holes

Chicco Physioform 100% soft silicone one-piece pacifier provides all the best features suitable for your breastfed baby. 

Its crowning feature for us is its lateral curved nipple design helps to distribute your baby’s tongue pressure against the palate. In addition, the tiny ridges of this pacifier help to correct not just your baby’s upper and bottom jaw, but his tongue movement during suckling.

Made from 100% Silicone material with no addition of BPA or latex, you rest assured that your baby’s health is not in any way compromised. Moreover, Its narrow base ensures complete lip closure at the bridge of the pacifier.

It comes with a functional shield design which comprises four air holes for proper ventilation and moisture removal.

Pros	Cons
The narrow base for lip closure	Plain-look
Comes with features that support your Child’s oral development

Key Features

• Brand: Philip’s Avent
• Age: 0-3 months 
• Material: 100% Silicone
• Toxicity: BPA free
• Type: Detachable pacifier
• Shield design: Stuffed Animal

Made from 100% super-soft silicon material, this toy-cum-pacifier is the best deal. 

The Pacifier features a plush and lightweight toy elephant your baby can snuggle on while he suckles, relieving you of the constant need to hold him.

When not in use, the plush toy helps you secure the pacifier safely. 

You don’t have to struggle to wash and clean. The Pacifier can easily be detached from the toy and thrown into your dishwasher or boiling water. The plush toy is conducive to machine washing. 

Philip Avent Soothie Snuggle Pacifier has been clinically proven to be completely free from BPA. It is no wonder, this Pacifier is well-loved by most buyers on Amazon.

Pros	Cons
The plush toy provides additional comfort to baby	The pacifier slips from the grip of the toy way too easily
Fast and easy to clean

Key Features

• Brand: Philip’s Avent
• Age: 0-3 months 
• Material: 100% Silicone
• Toxicity: BPA free
• Type: Detachable pacifier
• Shield design: Stuffed Animal

This is yet another 100% silicone-made pacifier. It features a flat symmetrical nipple-shaped tip that adapts to the shape of your baby’s tongue while suckling. It also features a thin neck that supports orthodontic developments in babies.

Its ergonomic design is in a way that meets the growing needs of your breastfed baby. It is incredibly lightweight and very easy to carry around. 

Its best feature for us is its sensopearls that allow for the flow of air between the pacifier and your baby’s sensitive skin.  

Pros	Cons
Sensopearls for airflow	Plain-looking
BPA-free
Lightweight

Why Every mother Must Own A Pacifier.

1. A very good means of calming a fussy baby
2. Helps to comfort preemie NICU babies while they recover in Intensive units. 
3. Promotes orthodontic developments in babies
4. Provide distractions to babies during hospital procedures
5. Reduces the risks associated with Sudden Infant Death Syndrome
6. Help your baby exercise his mouth muscles
7. Helps babies give in to sleep very quickly
8. Provides comfort during teething

Choosing the Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies: Tips to watch out for!

1. Size

Ensure that pacifier doesn’t come in too big or too small for your baby’s mouth. It must fit perfectly in her mouth without concerns of falling off.

2. Shape

For breastfed babies, round-tipped and nipple-shaped pacifiers are the best deal. The shape alone provides enough grip for your baby while she suckles.

3. Material

Pacifier must be made from 100% silicon materials with no addition of harmful chemicals like Latex, BPA and BPS.

4. Shield

Pacifiers shield must rest snugly on your baby’s face. In other words, the shield must not cover your baby’s face or even his nose, to avoid breathing problems.

5. Handle

The handle of the Pacifier must fit perfectly into your baby’s hand, for ease in suckling

6. Cleaning Options

Get a pacifier that can be washed in your average dishwasher.

When Should You Introduce A Pacifier To Your Breastfed Babies?

Before you introduce your baby to a pacifier, make sure your breastfeeding routine is well established.  In addition, you should also look out for signs showing that your baby is constantly putting on weight, that is,  6 weeks after birth.

When you introduce the pacifier way too early than you ought to, it could bear negative consequences by upsetting the balance between milk supply and natural breast stimulation.  

When To Wean Your Breastfed Baby From A Pacifier.

According to the American Academy of Family Physicians and American Academy of Paediatrics, you should avoid the prolonged use of a pacifier when you notice these signs in your breastfed baby.

1. Reduction in the baby’s feeding time
2. When your baby starts to develop thrush on his lips
3. Baby shows difficulties in gaining weight
4. When your baby exhibits reluctance in feeding
5. Increased risk of middle ear infection.
6. When your baby starts to demonstrate nipple confusion.

NOTE-The American Dental Association suggests you actively start to discontinue your baby’s use of a pacifier from the age of 4.

How to Balance Between A Pacifier and Breastfeeding.

1. Go for silicon options over Rubber.
2. Use Pacifiers in-between breastfeeding 
3. Never force a pacifier on your baby. 
4. Allow your baby to make the preference of their choice
5. Plan when you intend to wean your baby off the pacifier, preferably towards the end of their second/third year
6. Never assume your baby wants a pacifier whenever she starts to fuss, go for the option of breastfeeding first
7. Sterilize Pacifier as frequently as possible
8. Replace Pacifier as soon as you note any defects
9. Go for sturdy and one-piece options
10. Use Pacifiers appropriate to your baby’s weight and age

The Best Pacifier for Breastfed Babies: Our Verdict!

Choosing the best pacifier for your breastfed baby doesn’t have to be difficult any longer. We have curated a list above, for your selection.

However, our top pick for today is Dr Brown’s HappyPaci 100% Silicone Pacifier. It fits your breastfed baby suckling need as much as the real thing.